Key: Amazing Love Like Fine Dislike
Returnee season
Unlisted
Aviva Drescher - Ovivor: Nova Scotia, 12th [Feb '15]
Hali Ford - TV Stars: Paris, 4th [Apr 3 '15]
Xanthippe V. - Redvivor: Easter Island, 11th [Apr 5 '15]
Kelly Goldsmith - Ovivor: Ethiopia, 4th [Jun '15] & All-Stars, 7th [Dec 27 '15]
Riley Blue - Ovivor: Ireland, 14th [Aug 8 '15]
Hayley K. - Redvivor: Peru, 1st [Aug 14 '15] & Game Changers, 5th [Jun '17]1
Julia Nolan - TV Stars: Los Angeles, 5th [Aug 29 '15]
Joan Callamezzo - TV Stars: Superstar Showdown, Runner-up [Nov '15]
Angelica Turing - Redvivor: New Zealand, 8th [Dec 6 '15]
DJ Khaled - Toadvivor: Wisconsin, 8th [Jan '16]
Mitchie Torres - TV Stars: Around the World, 3rd [Mar '16]
Mega Rayquaza - Toadvivor: Jamaica, Winner [May '16]
Redmond Ovivor - Ovivor: Honduras, 5th [Jun 10 '16]
April Smith - TV Stars: Bollywood, 3rd [Jun 18 '16]
Michelle Meyer - TV Stars: Road Trip, Winner [Aug '16]
Tynnyfer - Redvivor: Portugal, 2nd runner-up [Sep '16]
Karen Singbeil - Epicvivor: Namibia, Winner [Apr '17]
Hunter H. - Redvivor: Mamanuca, Runner-up [May '17]
Johanna Soderberg - Epicvivor: The Amazon [Jun '17]
Apollo Smoothtap - Ovivor: Greece, 7th [May 29 '20]
Phoebe Bridgers - Redvivor: Patagonia, Runner-up [Jun 5 '20]
Angelina Keeley - Epicvivor: Norway, 3rd [Jun 13 '20]
1as AudreyBeckyBB17Fan
| Rank | Character | Season(s) | Placement(s) |
| 1st |  Scarlett |
Ovivor: Faroe Islands | 5th |
| 2nd |  JuddSergeant |
Ovivor: Kyushu | 4th |
| Ovivor: All-Stars | Winner | ||
| 3rd |  Larissa |
Epicvivor: Midway Island | 5th |
| Epicvivor: Heroes vs. Villains | 13th | ||
| Nalyd's Survivor: Samoa | Winner | ||
| 4th |  Yaxha |
Dravivor: Shifting Islands | Winner |
| Dravivor: Blood vs. Water | Winner | ||
| 5th |  Blendi |
Survivor: IRC Hollywood | 3rd |
| Toadvivor: Norway | Winner | ||
| 6th |  JaimeEdmondson |
Finale: Cirque du Soleil | 4th |
| 7th |  BrendaCaramoan |
Redvivor: Australia | Winner |
| Redvivor: All-Stars | 6th | ||
| 8th |  KhaiShing |
Finale: Yukon | 3rd |
| Finale: All-Stars | 11th | ||
| 9th |  JoanCallamezzo |
TV Stars Hawaii | 3rd |
| 10th |  Taystee |
Redvivor: India | Runner-Up |
| 11th |  Analapinquana |
FireVivor: The Sahara | Runner-Up |
| 12th |  TiffanyPDC PennsatuckyAS |
Epicvivor: Cambodia | Runner-Up |
| Epicvivor: All-Stars | 8th | ||
| 13th |  MaritzaRamos |
Redvivor: Angola | 5th |
| 14th |  AlizeTurntkey |
Dravivor: Tahiti | Second Runner-Up |
| 15th |  MicklePickle20 |
Spacevivor: New Zealand | 5th |
| 16th |  Blinks |
Dravivor: China | 9th |
| Dravivor: Caribbean | Runner-Up | ||
| 17th |  Bolin |
TV Stars Broadway | 9th |
| 18th |  LunaPlatz |
Epicvivor: Jamaica | 12th |
| 19th |  BrookRoberts |
Ovivor: Manchuria | Runner-Up |
| 20th |  NotPhione |
Epicvivor: Patagonia | 4th |
| 21st |  Vivillon |
Toadvivor: Greece | Second Runner-Up |
| 22nd |  HuntyQueenFierce |
Dravivor: New Zealand | Winner |
| 23rd |  RondiVazquez |
FireVivor: South Pacific | 5th |
| FireVivor: Ecuador | Runner-Up | ||
| FireVivor: Blood vs. Water | 11th | ||
| 24th |  Jesskya |
Toadvivor: Michigan | 8th |
| 25th |  Elizabeth |
Redvivor: Egypt | 6th |
| Rejectvivor: The Amazon | Runner-Up | ||
| 26th |  TayAllyn |
Ovivor: South Africa | 3rd |
| Ovivor: Fans vs. Favorites | 15th | ||
| 27th |  StarrForsythe |
Dravivor: Rivas | Runner-Up |
| 28th |  Caitlin |
Dravivor: Cambodia | 4th |
| 29th |  DarkHorse |
Redvivor: China | Runner-Up |
| 30th |  DarekLush |
Ovivor: Bali | 10th |
| 31st |  ShaneToutdroit |
FireVivor: Blood vs. Water | 10th |
| 32nd |  Nakum |
Dravivor: Blood vs. Water | 4th |
| 33rd |  SteffAndBae |
Dravivor: Romania | 6th |
| 34th |  Brunabi-Mana |
Survivor: IRC Desert | 6th |
| 35th |  SharpayEvans |
Survivor: IRC Holidays | 7th |
| 36th |  StacyKimball |
Epicvivor: Japan | 9th |
| 37th |  ZIPZAP CAT |
Epicvivor: Pearl Islands | 7th |
| 38th |  RicNielsen |
Redvivor: Panama | 9th |
| Firedvivor: Reddy vs. Fire | 10th | ||
| 39th |  EliasForsythe |
Dravivor: Rivas | 3rd |
| 40th |  donaam |
Ovivor: Turkey | 11th |
| 41st |  INVivillon |
Epicvivor: Malaysia | 10th |
| Rejectvivor: Australia | 3rd | ||
| 42nd |  Althea |
DukeVivor 1 | 7th |
| Rejectvivor | 13th | ||
| 43rd |  Clarq |
RedSurvivor II | 9th |
| 44th |  LadyMacbeth |
Redvivor: Hawaii | 10th |
| 45th |  Seekay |
FireVivor: Season One | 8th |
| FireVivor: Redemption Island | 7th | ||
| 46th |  Merlin |
FireVivor: Cape Horn | Winner |
| 47th |  JessicaM |
Finale: Berwick Castle | Runner-Up |
| 48th |  RichardMaganda |
Ovivor: Cagayan | Winner |
| 49th |  UTRManaphy |
Epicvivor: Patagonia | 11th |
| 50th |  UTRPrinplup |
Rejectvivor: Australia | 11th |
| 51st |  UTRhyhorn |
Epicvivor: Malaysia | 13th |
| 52nd |  Blake |
Dravivor: Lost Islands | 10th |
| 53rd |  Tipseekay |
Epicvivor: Egypt | 10th |
| 54th |  CourtneyYates |
Survivor: IRC Island | 11th |
| 55th |  jameZ |
FireVivor: Gabon | 8th |
| 56th |  LauraDyse |
Epicvivor: Antarctica | 8th |