| Contestant | Tribe Affiliation | Finish | Votes Against | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original Tribe | Merged Tribe | |||
| Marissa Hurley AshleyHikari |
Zhubei | 1st Voted Out Day 3 |
3 | |
| BartBaker TDfan10 |
Zhubei | Hit By Falling Palm Tree Day 6 |
2 | |
| MargaretThatcher Ben109 |
Dasi | 2nd Voted Out Day 9 |
5 | |
| HillaryClinton NateNJ14 |
Dasi | 3rd Voted Out Day 12 |
5 | |
| JermeyColin LucinaFTW |
Dasi | 4th Voted Out Day 15 |
3 | |
| Jamie Ginga Ninja Jack |
Dasi | Amethyst | 5th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 18 |
5 |
| GwenCarter Sunslicer2 |
Dasi | 4th Voted Out 2nd Jury Member Day 14 |
4 | |
| Hazel Shadowgeoff |
Zhubei | 5th Voted Out 3rd Jury Member Day 16 |
3 | |
| FlamePrincess Blondieee |
Dasi | 6th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 18 |
2 | |
| Bridgette 1dra7 |
Zhubei | 7th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 20 |
3 | |
| RachelReilly Reddude |
Zhubei | Runner-Up | 8 | |
| Sugilite JERealize |
Zhubei | Sole Epicvivor | 0 | |
Memorable Moments[]
- Marissa Hurley being intended to be a compelling, CP character, only to be voted out first over Bart Baker, who annoyed everyone.
- Reddy playing Rachel... again.
- Ashley's bemoaning Marissa's fate and asking for Outcasts the entire rest of the RP.
- BartBaker being hated by everyone on chat, causing an outrage when he survived the first vote.
- BartBaker being hit by a falling palm tree after Benji's mom made him go to bed.
- No one being able to determine whether Nate was HillaryClinton or MargaretThatcher, causing Ben, who was playing a parody of Nate, to be voted out over the real Nate.
- JermeyColin just spewing out misspelled, gramatically incorrect versions of things Jeremy Collins said on Survivor before his elimination.
- Epic reading the votes however they were sent, causing Jermey's always-misspelled, lowercase votes to be glaringly obvious.
- Jamie being a generic CPP young male.
- GwenCarter being a generic MORN bitch.
- Jamie and Gwen's ensuing rivalry, who no one really cared about except Sunny and Jack.
- The terrible merge tribe names submitted by everyone, causing Sugilite's lukewarm "Amethyst" to win out over suggestions like Jamie's "Hella" and Bridgette's "SurfShack."
- Hazel deciding to vote for Jamie just because he said submitted "Hella."
- Hazel at first being loyal to her source material and warning more volatile characters not to be disturb the island spirits, but being derailed shortly before her elimination because SG was going into 3AM mode.
- FlamePrincess ironically losing a firemaking challenge to Rachel at final four.
- Dylan accusing Epic of rigging the tiebreaker after being eliminated.
- Rachel finishing as runner-up... again.
- Sugilite beating Rachel at FTC, causing a very strange fight between Reddy and JE, which resulted in JE leaving the wiki for about 45 minutes.