|Contestant||Original Tribe||Mutinied Tribe||Merged Tribe||Finish|
|Funnyyyy Jokes||1st Voted Out|
|Poopy Ass Dicks||2nd Voted Out|
|Poopy Ass Dicks||3rd Voted Out|
|Funnyyyy Jokes||4th Voted Out|
|Poopy Ass Dicks||Poopy Ass Dicks||5th Voted Out|
|Funnyyyy Jokes||Funnyyyy Jokes||Anthony!||6th Voted Out|
1st Jury Member
|Poopy Ass Dicks||Funnyyyy Jokes||7th Voted Out|
2nd Jury Member
|Funnyyyy Jokes||Funnyyyy Jokes||8th Voted Out|
3rd Jury Member
|Funnyyyy Jokes||Funnyyyy Jokes||9th Voted Out|
4th Jury Member
|Poopy Ass Dicks||Poopy Ass Dicks||10th Voted Out|
5th Jury Member
|Funnyyyy Jokes||Funnyyyy Jokes||11th Voted Out|
8th Jury Member
|Funnyyyy Jokes||Funnyyyy Jokes||12th Voted Out|
8th Jury Member
|Poopy Ass Dicks||Poopy Ass Dicks||Runner-Up|
|Poopy Ass Dicks||Funnyyyy Jokes||Sole Survivor|
- As usual, almost everyone playing obnoxious OTT male characters to appeal to Toad, and succeeding.
- Toad downing seven shots of Skol vodka an hour before the RP started, for a more "casual, lighthearted" feel, resulting in the bizarre theme/title/tribe names.
- Toad pre-recording the instructions for every challenge in the form of a vlog (with CK's help), and Snapchatting them to every contestant.
- JeffSessions doing absolutely nothing. Like not even having one single line at all. Fuck you Nate.
- Ben's character, JanitorJonah, being a janitor going through a full-scale midlife crisis and captivating the entire audience, but then getting voted out second before his plot even started.
- TBTDIF and MrE playing Jon and Garfielf to shamelessly pander to Toad, and Toad "influencing" some of the early challenges in their favor.
- MrE going inactive around the beginning of round 3, giving Jon nobody to play off of and forcing him to spiral into TBTDIF's usual late-game nonsensical rambling, a la Garfield Without Garfield.
- Toad letting Nick and Kyle join, and them just shitposting as anime characters the entire time.
- Jax "playing against type" as Scary Terry, and even finding himself aligned with the chill MOR white dudes/shitposters for the first time ever.
- SG playing that guy from the Survivor: Zootopia FTC who was casually wearing a fursuit the whole time, and eventually becoming the biggest strategic force in the season.
- Ika Wong being hilariously out of place in this season and getting bodied pre-merge.
- The highly controversial mutiny, where the only contestants to mutiny were Mikan Tsumiki and Joseph Joestar, who only mutinied in the first place to join TBTDIF's tribe and annoy him with M E M E S.
- Epic playing Ciera Fields, a hybrid of Ciera and Cirie, and beast moding strategy until his untimely demise as a result of the mutiny.
- The iconic "Get Me A Date" Challenge returning, where the final six had to log onto Toad's Tinder account, message a randomly assigned girl, and the first one to get a phone number or Snapchat in response won.
- Toad receiving nudes as a result of this challenge (though not from one of the Tinder girls, from 1dra7).
- FrankieGrande somehow being even worse than his Big Brother 16 showing, due to relentless Dra spamming/gamebotting.
- NickThePrick's character, who just spouted anime references and posted memes the whole time, winning completely on accident (with almost a perfect game, ruined by one sole vote for Dra from TBTDIF).